The Bible is considered by Jews and Christians alike to be a holy book, one that is divinely inspired. However, despite being the best-selling book of all time, its interpretation and contents have generated controversy and a wide range of opinions throughout history, even among believers themselves—causing many different views across the world.
For us Christians, we consider the Bible as God’s word, written to guide us in our faith journey. Ironically, the Christian religion itself consists of numerous diverse denominations, each with its own interpretation of the Bible. For instance, Protestants and Catholics hold differing views regarding various principles and issues.
What’s interesting is that within Protestantism, there are numerous distinct interpretations of the Bible. A more metaphorical or symbolic view of the Bible is held by some denominations, while a literal interpretation is held by others. For example, some evangelicals think that every word in the Bible is accurate and should be accepted literally. Meanwhile, other denominations feel that certain sections are allegorical or metaphorical, and as such, should be regarded as symbolic.
These disagreements cause a lot of people to ask the question, “Why has the Bible caused so many different views and beliefs?
It’s All About Context
Perhaps the most important factor influencing the differences in biblical views and beliefs is context. While the Bible is considered as a sacred text by both Christians and Jews, it is important to understand that it was originally written for the Jews.
This indicates that the Bible was crafted in a particular historical and cultural setting. It is important for non-Jews to comprehend this if they are to completely appreciate its significance.
As you may already know, the Bible is divided into two major parts: The Old Testament and the New Testament. The Old Testament, also known as the Hebrew Bible, is where you’ll find the holy writings of Judaism. Originally written in Hebrew, the Old Testament is also referred to as the ‘Tanakh’ by the Jews.
Meanwhile, the New Testament is where you’ll find the Gospels, the Acts of the Apostles, letters, and the Book of Revelation. This is the body of literature that is essential to the Christian faith and was originally written in Greek.
Because the books were written for various audiences in various eras and cultures, there are discrepancies in how the Bible has been interpreted over the years. For instance, the rules and laws one can read in the Old Testament may not be applicable to our modern society because they were intended for the ancient Israelites.
Additionally, the letters written by the Apostle Paul may not be immediately applicable to today’s readers because they were written to address particular problems and dilemmas of early Christian communities, such as the Ephesian and Corinthian churches.
The fact that the Bible is a collection of writings that have been translated and transmitted over time is another factor contributing to the many different views and beliefs regarding the Bible. Books of the Bible were initially written in Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek, and over the years, many different languages have been used to interpret and even translate them.
Various translations may use different words or phrases to communicate the same exact notion. This is the reason some words or even verses are present in some translations but are absent from others. This, among other reasons, has led not only to differences but inaccuracies and inconsistencies.
The Role of Hermeneutics
Hermeneutics may not be a word many Christians encounter daily, but it’s one of the major reasons the Bible has caused so many different views and beliefs. It is the study of interpretation and is a practice used to understand the meaning of ancient writings, such as the Bible. Hermeneutics can take on a variety of forms, each of which might result in various Bible interpretations.
The historical-critical technique is one approach to hermeneutics that stresses the historical and cultural setting of the Bible’s composition. Using the social, political, and theological context of the period, this method aims to interpret the Bible as a historical record. This method can assist to reveal the Bible’s original meaning and can lead to a more sophisticated understanding of the book.
Meanwhile, there’s also the literal approach to hermeneutics, which stresses the straightforward meaning of biblical texts. According to this perspective, the Bible should be read and interpreted just as it is written, devoid of any other interpretation. This method may result in a more direct and literal understanding of the Bible, but it could overlook the text’s historical and cultural context.
An allegorical method is a third approach to hermeneutics that focuses on the text’s symbolic or metaphorical significance. According to this perspective, the Bible should be read and comprehended on many levels, with varied interpretations for many readers. This method may not be as historically accurate as the historical-critical method, but it can result in a more mystical and spiritual reading of the Bible.
As you can see, there are different theories and approaches to interpreting the Bible, which is one reason adherents can’t seem to agree with how they should apply God’s words. Moreover, each method has its own advantages and disadvantages, and individual readers may find that one method is more effective than another in helping them grasp the Bible.
Human Tendencies and Limitations
Human tendencies and limitations are another reason why it seems that the Bible has caused many different views and beliefs .The accuracy of biblical interpretation can be significantly impacted by human propensity and limitation. The propensity for reading our own biases and assumptions into the text is one of the main human characteristics that might affect interpretation.
Instead of trying to comprehend the text’s genuine meaning, this might result in interpreting it in a way that supports our own opinions. Furthermore, instead of comprehending what the text truly means, we could interpret a section in a way that advances our own political or social agenda.
Understanding the text’s historical and cultural context only to a limited extent is another shortcoming we have as humans that might influence our interpretation of the Bible. It might be challenging to comprehend a text’s meaning in its entirety without having a thorough comprehension of the context in which it was written. For instance, how can we accurately translate a work written in ancient Hebrew without a thorough knowledge of Hebrew language and culture?
Our propensity as humans to insert our own cultural or historical background into the text also has an impact on interpretation. This can cause the content to be interpreted in a way that is inappropriate given its original context. For instance, it would not be correct to read a writing from antiquity using contemporary cultural standards or values.
Lack of familiarity with other biblical texts—not just those in the same book but also those in other books of the bible—is another drawback. Without a thorough comprehension of the whole canon of scripture, it can be challenging to comprehend a text’s meaning in its entirety.
Additionally, we humans often impose the perspective of one discipline on biblical texts. For instance, reading exclusively from a literary perspective might be restrictive because the text may signify something quite different from a historical or sociological standpoint.
A Difficult Yet Necessary Endeavor
The Bible has caused so many different views and beliefs as a result of the reasons mentioned above. The question one might ask is whether a time will come when the bible-believing community will ever unite and have the same interpretation and application of the Holy Bible. Nothing is impossible, but if adherents of the Bible are to achieve unity, we need to embrace the truth that it’s going to be a laborious endeavor.
But even if Bible-believing people will not reach unity, it is not too late for us to develop a deeper appreciation and regard for one another’s viewpoints, which can promote more collaboration and unity in our community.
Check out some of our other posts!